'Big Dollars, Little Sense': Community and Student Groups Debunk Charter School Mythology

ENEWSFUSE November 6, 2020 No Comments

Policies pushed by Mayor Rahm Emanuel and decisions being made by the Chicago Public Schools (CPS) are swindling the parents, teachers and students in the name of privatization, charter school expansion, and corporate-backed education reforms.

That is the charge being levied by a band of student and community groups who on Tuesday released a new report, , in which they examined the numbers used by CPS to justify the closure of public schools and the expansion of charter schools across the city.

Members of and , who commissioned the report, along with other concerned parents, students and community members rallied outside the CPS headquarters Tuesday to present their findings to the city and call on the Board of Education (BOE) to take their objections seriously.

“It’s not right that CPS is lying to the people to justify these charter expansions,” declared one student, named Sarah, a representative from CSOSOS.

“BOE, after stealing $168 million from neighborhood schools, now wants 52 new charters,” wrote the student advocacy group on their Facebook page. “Smells like privatization of public education!” 

“At the level of state and federal education policy,” writes Stan Karp at Rethinking Schools, “charters are providing a reform cover for eroding the public school system and an investment opportunity for those who see education as a business rather than a fundamental institution of democratic civic life.”

SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT

Click Here: maori all blacks rugby jersey

In August, the BOE voted to cut classroom spending by $168 million for the 2013-14 school year which critics promised would have a “devastating impact” on the city’s neighborhood schools. According to the groups, that decision was put forth just 16 days after CPS “quietly” released a new ‘Request for Proposals’ (RFP) for charter school expansion to supposedly relieve overcrowding in some of those same communities.

In response, the community groups conducted an independent analysis of CPS’ rationale for charter expansion and the impact that it will have on neighborhood schools.

Among their findings, the report concludes:

  1. CPS uses inaccurate and misleading data in order to justify charter expansion, such as using inaccurate boundaries for community areas to overstate the overcrowding crisis, and excluding additional classroom space such as mobile classrooms and leased classroom space when calculating community area utilization rates .
  2. Traditional CPS schools are more than twice as likely to receive a top performance level rating than a charter school in Chicago .
  3. In the last two years alone, traditional CPS school bud- gets were cut by a total of $351 million, while charter school spending increased by more than $143 million to $570 million.
  4. According to CPS’ funding formula, a single new charter school would cost taxpayers up to $2 .9 in upfront revenue that CPS automatically provides and could cost up to $2 million in additional expenses every subsequent year. The 12 schools that CPS is considering through the RFP process could collectively cost taxpayers anywhere between $13 .8 to 34 .8 million in a single year alone. These are not dollars attached to students; rather these are new expenditures that taxpayers would have to pay for. Additionally, because of CPS’ new Student Based Budgeting formula, as new charters pull students away from neighborhood schools, financial resources for neighborhood schools would be further depleted over time.
  5. Some examples include redrawing attendance boundaries and making targeted investments to increase a school’s capacity such as building mobile classroom units on site. These solutions could save taxpayers millions of dollars, while investing in existing neighbor-hood schools .

The Board of Education is expected to decide on any new charter schools in January.

Read the full report below or download it here:

Big Dollars Little Sense Report

_________________________________________________

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *